Catholic Hospital Faces Lawsuit for Transgender Discrimination

The California Appeals court reinstated a lawsuit against Dignity Health, a Catholic hospital chain, filed after they barred a hysterectomy for a transgender patient. The court found that the state’s interest in fighting LGBTQ discrimination outweighs the facility’s alleged right to impose religious standards on healthcare they provide.

The patient denied a hysterectomy who filed suit against Dignity Health was Evan Minton. Minton’s hysterectomy surgery was cancelled abruptly in 2016 when officials at Dignity’s Mercy San Juan Medical Center in Carmichael, California discovered he was transgender. The hospital claims their actions in cancelling Minton’s surgery complied with the church’s ethical and religious directives for Catholic Health Care Services that prohibit sterilization procedures except in very rare circumstances.

The appeals court found in favor of the patient stating that any burden California places on the exercise of religion is justified by the state’s interest in ensuring equal access to medical treatment for all residents regardless of sexual orientation. The case will return to San Francisco County Superior Court for further proceedings and trial. The appellate court’s ruling may limit the ability of Catholic health facilities in California to limit what healthcare services are provided to patients. A number of procedures are forbidden by the previously cited Ethical and Religious Directives. Most denied treatments and procedures are associated with women’s reproductive rights, end-of-life care, and treatments for transgender patients.

In the Ethical and Religious Directives document, certain treatments and procedures are described as “intrinsically evil.” Some of these treatments include abortion, euthanasia, direct sterilization, and assisted suicide. Administrators and employees of the facility are barred from assisting patients with these procedures or referring them to outside providers for the services. Local bishops must approve any exceptions.

If you need help due to discrimination in the workplace or if you need to file an employment law lawsuit, please get in touch with one of Blumenthal Nordrehaug Bhowmik DeBlouw LLP’s offices in San Diego, San Francisco, Sacramento, Los Angeles, Riverside or Chicago.